diamonds ·

How To Buy A Loose Diamond

Loose diamonds offer unmatched control over quality, price, and design. But with freedom comes complexity. For serious buyers—especially those creating custom fine jewelry—understanding how to evaluate and source a loose diamond is essential to making a smart, lasting investment.

At Mervis Diamond Importers, we don’t just sell diamonds—we import them directly from the world’s finest cutting centers. With over 80 years of experience and roots in Johannesburg, South Africa, we’ve built a reputation on precision, transparency, and personalized guidance. This guide distills that expertise into an elegant, actionable roadmap to help you buy the perfect loose diamond.

What Is a Loose Diamond?

A loose diamond is an unset stone—sold on its own, before being placed into a ring, pendant, or other jewelry design. It gives you flexibility and full transparency when selecting:

  • The shape and size

  • The cut quality and sparkle

  • The color and clarity balance

  • The best value within your budget

At Mervis, loose diamonds are our specialty. Each one is hand-selected, independently graded, and ready to be set in the design of your choice—or simply added to your personal collection.

Why It’s Worth Buying Loose

Purchasing a loose diamond—rather than one that’s already set—lets you:

  • See the diamond clearly from every angle, without metal distracting the view

  • Compare quality side-by-side with other stones

  • Create a custom piece around your chosen stone

  • Avoid overpaying for brand markups or preset styles

In short, it’s the most transparent way to understand what you're buying—and ensure every detail meets your standards.

Step 1: Begin With Your Vision

Before reviewing stones, define your goals:

  • Is this diamond for a solitaire ring, multi-stone piece, or standalone investment?

  • Do you envision a classic, romantic, or modern design?

  • Which is more important: visual size, sparkle, or rarity?

  • What is your ideal budget for the diamond, excluding the setting?

Clarity in your preferences ensures your final selection will reflect both personal taste and practical value.

Step 2: Understand the 4Cs with Precision

Cut: The Cornerstone of Brilliance

The cut of a diamond affects how well it handles light. It’s the most critical factor for sparkle.

  • Ideal/Excellent Cut – Maximizes brilliance, fire, and scintillation.

  • Proportions – Look for optimal table size, depth percentage, and symmetry.

  • Light Performance – A properly cut diamond reflects light from every angle.

At Mervis, we recommend prioritizing cut above all. Even a high-carat diamond will look dull if the cut is poor.

Color: Grading Subtlety

Color is graded from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow/brown). Most buyers prefer the G–H range, which balances beauty and value.

  • D–F: Premium colorless

  • G–H: Near-colorless and excellent value

  • I–J: Slight warmth, ideal in yellow gold settings

Our advisors help you view color side-by-side in controlled lighting, so you can see the differences clearly—something online buying can never replicate.

Clarity: Eye-Clean vs. Overpaying

Clarity evaluates internal inclusions and surface blemishes.

  • VS1–VS2: Often eye-clean

  • SI1–SI2: Can offer excellent value if inclusions are positioned well

  • IF–VVS: Extremely rare, often premium-priced

A trained eye (like ours) can help identify diamonds that are technically “lower” clarity but completely clean to the naked eye—saving you money without sacrificing beauty.

Carat: The Balance of Weight and Proportion

Carat measures weight, not visual size. A 1.00 ct diamond may not look much bigger than a 0.90 ct—but the price jump can be steep.

Pro tip: Consider just below major thresholds (0.90 ct, 1.40 ct, 1.80 ct) for better value with little to no visual difference.

Step 3: Choose the Right Shape

Diamond shape impacts not only style—but also how large the stone appears.

Your diamond’s shape should complement the design of your setting—but the stone should lead the way.

Step 4: Insist on Trusted Certification

A reputable grading report ensures transparency and protects your investment.

We recommend certification from:

  • GIA (Gemological Institute of America)

  • AGS (American Gem Society)

  • IGI (International Gemological Institute)

Each report outlines cut, color, clarity, carat, proportions, and fluorescence. At Mervis, we only present diamonds with trusted, verifiable documentation—and we personally walk you through every detail.

All loose diamonds from Mervis are laser-inscribed and accompanied by full grading dossiers for authenticity and insurance purposes.

Step 5: Inspect It in Person

No amount of paperwork replaces your own eyes. When buying a loose diamond, request to:

  • View the stone under 10x magnification

  • Compare it in daylight and showroom lighting

  • Rotate it slowly to evaluate fire and scintillation

  • Place it on the skin or near metal to observe how it interacts with color

Mervis showrooms are designed to help you make that visual judgment with confidence, guided by trained gemologists—not commission-based sellers.

Design and Setting Considerations

Once you’ve chosen your diamond, it’s time to envision the finished piece. A proper setting should both enhance and protect the stone.

Key questions to explore:

  • Will the diamond be elevated or low-profile in the design?

  • What metal tone will complement the diamond’s color grade?

  • Do you need a protective setting for a delicate shape (e.g., marquise or pear)?

  • Would a halo, pavé band, or three-stone design suit your vision?

At Mervis, we offer custom design consultations, as well as curated designer settings exclusive to our showrooms. Every piece is crafted with precision and built to showcase your selected stone to its fullest potential.

Protecting Your Investment

To ensure long-term peace of mind, take these steps once your diamond is selected:

  • Obtain an insurance appraisal based on the diamond’s certification

  • Store all documentation in a safe and secure place

  • Schedule periodic maintenance once your diamond is set

  • Consider upgrade opportunities if future milestones call for a change

We support our clients well beyond the point of purchase, offering expert care, appraisals, and upgrade options tailored to your long-term goals.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I upgrade my diamond later?

Yes. Mervis offers a lifetime trade-in policy on all our natural diamonds, allowing you to upgrade while preserving your investment.

Do you offer lab-grown diamonds?

We do. Lab-grown diamonds offer exceptional value and brilliance. Each one is certified and rigorously evaluated, and can be matched to both classic and custom settings.

Can I begin the process online?

Absolutely. You may begin with a virtual consultation or explore our inventory online. Our diamond experts are available to curate selections in advance of your showroom visit.

Final Thoughts: The Mervis Standard

Buying a loose diamond is an invitation to participate in the most refined form of jewelry acquisition—an act of discernment, intention, and personal expression. At Mervis Diamond Importers, we provide the expertise, selection, and integrity to ensure your choice reflects the full measure of your vision.

With direct sourcing, custom design capabilities, and a reputation built on trust, we invite you to experience what makes Mervis the most distinguished destination for certified loose diamonds in Washington DC, Maryland, and Virginia.

Begin Your Diamond Journey Today

  • Schedule a Private Appointment

  • Explore Our Loose Diamond Collection

  • Speak to a Diamond Expert

At Mervis Diamond Importers, brilliance begins long before the setting.

Back to Blog